(转) The care and maintenance of your adviser

简介: The care and maintenance of your adviser Ever since the advent of graduate school, students have complained about their advisers.

The care and maintenance of your adviser

 

Ever since the advent of graduate school, students have complained about their advisers. It is almost an article of faith. The adviser is never available or is too available; gives too much feedback or not enough; is too critical or isn't providing enough direction; and so on. Exchanging horror stories with other students is a great way to bond. But advising goes both ways — and if, after careful reflection on their own studies and progress, students determine that they are not getting the guidance they require, they must address the deficiencies.

It is not surprising that advisers figure large in graduate students' conversations. In 2009, the US Council of Graduate Schools in Washington DC reported survey results showing that 65% of the 1,856 doctoral students who responded identified mentoring or advising as a main factor in PhD completion. Our own research at Flinders University in Adelaide, Australia, and our experience at graduate-student workshops across the world suggest that the adviser–student relationship has a big impact on completion time. It certainly influences whether students are still smiling at the end of their degrees!

Students often assume that once they call someone an adviser, he or she automatically acquires all the skills of advising. After all, if your adviser is the world leader in stem-cell technology, he or she must excel at the seemingly simple task of advising — not to mention possess highly developed interpersonal skills and a keen interest in graduate-student development. Sadly, that is not the case.

 

IMAGES.COM/CORBIS

Sometimes, advising is a weakness of an otherwise very accomplished scientist. This is not surprising. Mentoring tends to be a private business, and often the only model available is an adviser's own experience of having been advised. If it was good, they decide to copy that style and methodology; if it was bad, they do the opposite. There is no guarantee that either approach will provide the student with the guidance he or she needs.

A proactive approach is necessary. If your adviser isn't looking after you in the way you need, then you need to look after them. At some point in the PhD journey, most graduate students come to an important realization: “This is my thesis. My name is written on the front of it. I need to become the driver.” The sooner the candidate does this, the better. If you're not getting feedback, clear direction or the necessary resources, then you must do something about it. What does this mean in practice? Let us take some examples.

Meetings

A comment we often hear at our workshops is, “My adviser is lovely but he/she is just so busy that we never get to talk about my thesis”. And our response is, “Yes, your adviser is busy. All advisers are busy and will continue to be busy. Regardless, you need to organize meetings where you can get real face time and talk about your thesis.” We're not recommending a quick chat in the coffee room or a brief word in the lab. Nor do we mean a lab meeting.

We mean regularly scheduled meetings focusing on your thesis. You will probably have to schedule them and follow up to make sure that they happen. And when a meeting is cancelled, you will have to reschedule it and persist until it happens.

In our experience, just scheduling the meeting isn't enough. You can't assume that your adviser hosts productive meetings or can intuit what you need to know. You need a specific, uncomplicated agenda that could include such action items as what you've done in the past two weeks; feedback on written work; what you'll do in the next two weeks; the next meeting.

This all sounds very straightforward. But if more students followed these steps, many adviser–student issues could be resolved.

Feedback

Again, in an ideal world, your adviser would be skilled at providing supportive comments, delicate in pointing out areas for improvement and deft at intuitively knowing the level of feedback you seek. But this is a fantasy. One student described her feedback experience as similar to being a victim in a drive-by shooting — she handed over her work, it was riddled with bullets and she was left with a bloodied mess as the shooter drove off.

To be fair, e-mailing a chapter to an adviser and saying “Give me feedback” is like walking into a restaurant and saying “Give me food.” You need to be a bit more specific. When handing over your work, identify the type of feedback you are looking for. You might say, “This is an early draft, so I just want feedback on the overall direction,” or “Please focus on the discussion on page six.” If the feedback you get isn't helpful, ask for more detail. Maintaining your adviser means asking for what you need rather than hoping that he or she will know what to provide.

Managing up

One of the secrets of looking after your adviser is working out what they want — and what most advisers want is a student who comes to them with suggestions and solutions as well as problems, gets things done and makes the job of advising easier. In business this is called 'managing up'. When we work with graduate students we call it the 'care and maintenance' of your adviser.

So although it is natural to complain about your adviser — and can even be cathartic — it is not enough. If your adviser is not giving you what you need, you need to go out and get it.

 


 

Reference: 

  https://www.nature.com/naturejobs/science/articles/10.1038/nj7331-570a

 

相关文章
Element el-select 选择器(下拉框)详解
本文目录 1. 用途 2. 数据绑定 2.1 固定选项 2.2 选项绑定数组 3. 功能效果 3.1 可清空选项 3.2 多选 3.3 可搜索 4. 事件响应 5. 小结
7102 0
Element el-select 选择器(下拉框)详解
HTML中的<br>、<hr>和<pre>标签使用指南
HTML中的<br>、<hr>和<pre>标签使用指南
925 2
|
9月前
|
存储 NoSQL 关系型数据库
从大数据到大模型:如何做到“心无桎梏,身无藩篱”
在大数据和大模型的加持下,现代数据技术释放了巨大的技术红利,通过多种数据范式解除了数据的桎梏,使得应用程序达到了“心无桎梏,身无藩篱”的自在境界,那么现代应用有哪些数据范式呢?这正是本文尝试回答的问题。
1500 101
|
10月前
|
监控 安全 Serverless
"揭秘D2终端大会热点技术:Serverless架构最佳实践全解析,让你的开发效率翻倍,迈向技术新高峰!"
【10月更文挑战第23天】D2终端大会汇聚了众多前沿技术,其中Serverless架构备受瞩目。它让开发者无需关注服务器管理,专注于业务逻辑,提高开发效率。本文介绍了选择合适平台、设计合理函数架构、优化性能及安全监控的最佳实践,助力开发者充分挖掘Serverless潜力,推动技术发展。
381 1
|
消息中间件 存储 运维
更优性能与性价比,从自建 ELK 迁移到 SLS 开始
本文介绍了 SLS 基本能力,并和开源自建 ELK 做了对比,可以看到 SLS 相比开源 ELK 有较大优势。
56084 250
|
自然语言处理 测试技术 异构计算
使用Accelerate库在多GPU上进行LLM推理
大型语言模型(llm)已经彻底改变了自然语言处理领域。随着这些模型在规模和复杂性上的增长,推理的计算需求也显著增加。为了应对这一挑战利用多个gpu变得至关重要。
2136 0
|
机器学习/深度学习 编解码 人工智能
2022最新综述 | 面向大规模场景的小目标检测:综述和 benchmark
目标检测在过去几年中取得了显著的进展,然而,由于小目标视觉特征较差、噪声较多,小目标检测已成为计算机视觉中最具有挑战性的任务之一。此外,用于小尺寸目标检测的大规模基准测试数据集仍然不够全面。本文首先对小目标检测方法进行了全面的回顾,除此之外,还构建了两个大规模小目标检测数据集(SODA),SODA-D和SODA-A,分别关注驾驶场景和空中场景。
2022最新综述 | 面向大规模场景的小目标检测:综述和 benchmark
|
并行计算 iOS开发 MacOS
Metal每日分享,调整胶片颗粒感滤镜效果
Metal每日分享,调整胶片颗粒感滤镜效果
Metal每日分享,调整胶片颗粒感滤镜效果
|
C语言
C语言-void类型作为万能指针类型
C语言-void类型作为万能指针类型
203 0
亮瞎男人双眼的小便池
    厕所是泛指人类建造的专门进行大小便的产所。最早的厕所可以追溯到2500年前的美索不达米亚地区,那时的厕所都是公共厕所,直到18世纪70年代,经历了工业革命的欧洲,特别是英、法开始在建筑物里设计室内厕所。
1289 0

热门文章

最新文章