背景

最近需要做这样一个事情，一个服务来完成多款App的录音功能，大致有如下逻辑

服务以lib的形式集成到各个端
当主App存在时，所有其他App都使用主App的录音服务
当主App不存在时，其他App使用自带录音服务
有优先级，优先级高的App有绝对的录音权限，不管其他App是否在录音都要暂停，优先处理高优先级的App请求
支持AudioRecord、MediaRecorder两种录音方案

为什么要这么设计？

Android系统底层对录音有限制，同一时间只支持一个进程使用录音的功能
业务需要，一切事务保证主App的录音功能
为了更好的管理录音状态，以及多App相互通信问题

架构图设计

App层

包含公司所有需要集成录音服务的端，这里不需要解释

Manager层

该层负责Service层的管理，包括：服务的绑定，解绑，注册回调，开启录音，停止录音，检查录音状态，检查服务运行状态等

Service层

核心逻辑层，通过AIDL的实现，来满足跨进程通信，并提供实际的录音功能。

目录一览

看代码目录的分配，并结合架构图，我们来从底层往上层实现一套逻辑

IRecorder 接口定义

public interface IRecorder {
    String startRecording(RecorderConfig recorderConfig);
    void stopRecording();
    RecorderState state();
    boolean isRecording();
}

IRecorder 接口实现

class JLMediaRecorder : IRecorder {
    private var mMediaRecorder: MediaRecorder? = null
    private var mState = RecorderState.IDLE
    @Synchronized
    override fun startRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig): String {
        try {
            mMediaRecorder = MediaRecorder()
            mMediaRecorder?.setAudioSource(recorderConfig.audioSource)
            when (recorderConfig.recorderOutFormat) {
                RecorderOutFormat.MPEG_4 -> {
                    mMediaRecorder?.setOutputFormat(MediaRecorder.OutputFormat.MPEG_4)
                    mMediaRecorder?.setAudioEncoder(MediaRecorder.AudioEncoder.AAC)
                }
                RecorderOutFormat.AMR_WB -> {
                    mMediaRecorder?.setOutputFormat(MediaRecorder.OutputFormat.AMR_WB)
                    mMediaRecorder?.setAudioEncoder(MediaRecorder.AudioEncoder.AMR_WB)
                }
                else -> {
                    mMediaRecorder?.reset()
                    mMediaRecorder?.release()
                    mMediaRecorder = null
                    return "MediaRecorder 不支持 AudioFormat.PCM"
                }
            }
        } catch (e: IllegalStateException) {
            mMediaRecorder?.reset()
            mMediaRecorder?.release()
            mMediaRecorder = null
            return "Error initializing media recorder 初始化失败";
        }
        return try {
            val file = recorderConfig.recorderFile
            file.parentFile.mkdirs()
            file.createNewFile()
            val outputPath: String = file.absolutePath
            mMediaRecorder?.setOutputFile(outputPath)
            mMediaRecorder?.prepare()
            mMediaRecorder?.start()
            mState = RecorderState.RECORDING
            ""
        } catch (e: Exception) {
            mMediaRecorder?.reset()
            mMediaRecorder?.release()
            mMediaRecorder = null
            recorderConfig.recorderFile.delete()
            e.toString()
        }
    }
    override fun isRecording(): Boolean {
        return mState == RecorderState.RECORDING
    }
    @Synchronized
    override fun stopRecording() {
        try {
            if (mState == RecorderState.RECORDING) {
                mMediaRecorder?.stop()
                mMediaRecorder?.reset()
                mMediaRecorder?.release()
            }
        } catch (e: java.lang.IllegalStateException) {
            e.printStackTrace()
        }
        mMediaRecorder = null
        mState = RecorderState.IDLE
    }
    override fun state(): RecorderState {
        return mState
    }
}

这里需要注意的就是加 @Synchronized 因为多进程同时调用的时候会出现状态错乱问题，需要加上才安全。

AIDL 接口定义

interface IRecorderService {
    void startRecording(in RecorderConfig recorderConfig);
    void stopRecording(in RecorderConfig recorderConfig);
    boolean isRecording(in RecorderConfig recorderConfig);
    RecorderResult getActiveRecording();
    void registerCallback(IRecorderCallBack callBack);
    void unregisterCallback(IRecorderCallBack callBack);
}

注意点：自定义参数需要实现Parcelable接口需要回调的话也是AIDL接口定义

AIDL 接口回调定义

interface IRecorderCallBack {
    void onStart(in RecorderResult result);
    void onStop(in RecorderResult result);
    void onException(String error,in RecorderResult result);
}

RecorderService 实现

接下来就是功能的核心，跨进程的服务

class RecorderService : Service() {
    private var iRecorder: IRecorder? = null
    private var currentRecorderResult: RecorderResult = RecorderResult()
    private var currentWeight: Int = -1
    private val remoteCallbackList: RemoteCallbackList<IRecorderCallBack> = RemoteCallbackList()
    private val mBinder: IRecorderService.Stub = object : IRecorderService.Stub() {
        override fun startRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig) {
            startRecordingInternal(recorderConfig)
        }
        override fun stopRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig) {
            if (recorderConfig.recorderId == currentRecorderResult.recorderId)
                stopRecordingInternal()
            else {
                notifyCallBack {
                    it.onException(
                        "Cannot stop the current recording because the recorderId is not the same as the current recording",
                        currentRecorderResult
                    )
                }
            }
        }
        override fun getActiveRecording(): RecorderResult? {
            return currentRecorderResult
        }
        override fun isRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig?): Boolean {
            return if (recorderConfig?.recorderId == currentRecorderResult.recorderId)
                iRecorder?.isRecording ?: false
            else false
        }
        override fun registerCallback(callBack: IRecorderCallBack) {
            remoteCallbackList.register(callBack)
        }
        override fun unregisterCallback(callBack: IRecorderCallBack) {
            remoteCallbackList.unregister(callBack)
        }
    }
    override fun onBind(intent: Intent?): IBinder? {
        return mBinder
    }
    @Synchronized
    private fun startRecordingInternal(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig) {
        val willStartRecorderResult =
            RecorderResultBuilder.aRecorderResult().withRecorderFile(recorderConfig.recorderFile)
                .withRecorderId(recorderConfig.recorderId).build()
        if (ContextCompat.checkSelfPermission(
                this@RecorderService,
                android.Manifest.permission.RECORD_AUDIO
            )
            != PackageManager.PERMISSION_GRANTED
        ) {
            logD("Record audio permission not granted, can't record")
            notifyCallBack {
                it.onException(
                    "Record audio permission not granted, can't record",
                    willStartRecorderResult
                )
            }
            return
        }
        if (ContextCompat.checkSelfPermission(
                this@RecorderService,
                android.Manifest.permission.WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE
            )
            != PackageManager.PERMISSION_GRANTED
        ) {
            logD("External storage permission not granted, can't save recorded")
            notifyCallBack {
                it.onException(
                    "External storage permission not granted, can't save recorded",
                    willStartRecorderResult
                )
            }
            return
        }
        if (isRecording()) {
            val weight = recorderConfig.weight
            if (weight < currentWeight) {
                logD("Recording with weight greater than in recording")
                notifyCallBack {
                    it.onException(
                        "Recording with weight greater than in recording",
                        willStartRecorderResult
                    )
                }
                return
            }
            if (weight > currentWeight) {
                //只要权重大于当前权重，立即停止当前。
                stopRecordingInternal()
            }
            if (weight == currentWeight) {
                if (recorderConfig.recorderId == currentRecorderResult.recorderId) {
                    notifyCallBack {
                        it.onException(
                            "The same recording cannot be started repeatedly",
                            willStartRecorderResult
                        )
                    }
                    return
                } else {
                    stopRecordingInternal()
                }
            }
            startRecorder(recorderConfig, willStartRecorderResult)
        } else {
            startRecorder(recorderConfig, willStartRecorderResult)
        }
    }
    private fun startRecorder(
        recorderConfig: RecorderConfig,
        willStartRecorderResult: RecorderResult
    ) {
        logD("startRecording result ${willStartRecorderResult.toString()}")
        iRecorder = when (recorderConfig.recorderOutFormat) {
            RecorderOutFormat.MPEG_4, RecorderOutFormat.AMR_WB -> {
                JLMediaRecorder()
            }
            RecorderOutFormat.PCM -> {
                JLAudioRecorder()
            }
        }
        val result = iRecorder?.startRecording(recorderConfig)
        if (!result.isNullOrEmpty()) {
            logD("startRecording result $result")
            notifyCallBack {
                it.onException(result, willStartRecorderResult)
            }
        } else {
            currentWeight = recorderConfig.weight
            notifyCallBack {
                it.onStart(willStartRecorderResult)
            }
            currentRecorderResult = willStartRecorderResult
        }
    }
    private fun isRecording(): Boolean {
        return iRecorder?.isRecording ?: false
    }
    @Synchronized
    private fun stopRecordingInternal() {
        logD("stopRecordingInternal")
        iRecorder?.stopRecording()
        currentWeight = -1
        iRecorder = null
        MediaScannerConnection.scanFile(
            this,
            arrayOf(currentRecorderResult.recorderFile?.absolutePath),
            null,
            null
        )
        notifyCallBack {
            it.onStop(currentRecorderResult)
        }
    }
    private fun notifyCallBack(done: (IRecorderCallBack) -> Unit) {
        val size = remoteCallbackList.beginBroadcast()
        logD("recorded notifyCallBack  size $size")
        (0 until size).forEach {
            done(remoteCallbackList.getBroadcastItem(it))
        }
        remoteCallbackList.finishBroadcast()
    }
}

这里需要注意的几点：因为是跨进程服务，启动录音的时候有可能是多个app在同一时间启动，还有可能在一个App录音的同时，另一个App调用停止的功能，所以这里维护好当前currentRecorderResult对象的维护，还有一个currentWeight字段也很重要，这个字段主要是维护优先级的问题，只要有比当前优先级高的指令，就按新的指令操作录音服务。 notifyCallBack 在合适时候调用AIDL回调，通知App做相应的操作。

RecorderManager 实现

step 1 服务注册，这里按主App的包名来启动，所有App都是以这种方式启动

fun initialize(context: Context?, serviceConnectState: ((Boolean) -> Unit)? = null) {
       mApplicationContext = context?.applicationContext
       if (!isServiceConnected) {
           this.mServiceConnectState = serviceConnectState
           val serviceIntent = Intent()
           serviceIntent.`package` = "com.julive.recorder"
           serviceIntent.action = "com.julive.audio.service"
           val isCanBind = mApplicationContext?.bindService(
               serviceIntent,
               mConnection,
               Context.BIND_AUTO_CREATE
           ) ?: false
           if (!isCanBind) {
               logE("isCanBind:$isCanBind")
               this.mServiceConnectState?.invoke(false)
               bindSelfService()
           }
       }
   }

isCanBind 是false的情况，就是未发现主App的情况，这个时候就需要启动自己的服务

private fun bindSelfService() {
        val serviceIntent = Intent(mApplicationContext, RecorderService::class.java)
        val isSelfBind =
            mApplicationContext?.bindService(serviceIntent, mConnection, Context.BIND_AUTO_CREATE)
        logE("isSelfBind:$isSelfBind")
    }

step 2 连接成功后

private val mConnection: ServiceConnection = object : ServiceConnection {
        override fun onServiceConnected(name: ComponentName, service: IBinder) {
            mRecorderService = IRecorderService.Stub.asInterface(service)
            mRecorderService?.asBinder()?.linkToDeath(deathRecipient, 0)
            isServiceConnected = true
            mServiceConnectState?.invoke(true)
        }
        override fun onServiceDisconnected(name: ComponentName) {
            isServiceConnected = false
            mRecorderService = null
            logE("onServiceDisconnected:name=$name")
        }
    }

接下来就可以用mRecorderService 来操作AIDL接口，最终调用RecorderService的实现

//启动
fun startRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig?) {
        if (recorderConfig != null)
            mRecorderService?.startRecording(recorderConfig)
    }
//暂停
    fun stopRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig?) {
        if (recorderConfig != null)
            mRecorderService?.stopRecording(recorderConfig)
    }
//是否录音中
    fun isRecording(recorderConfig: RecorderConfig?): Boolean {
        return mRecorderService?.isRecording(recorderConfig) ?: false
    }

这样一套完成的跨进程通信就完成了，代码注释很少，经过这个流程的代码展示，应该能明白整体的调用流程。如果有不明白的，欢迎留言区哦。

总结

通过这两天，对这个AIDL实现的录音服务，对跨进程的数据处理有了更加深刻的认知，这里面有几个比较难处理的就是录音的状态维护，还有就是优先级的维护，能把这两点整明白其实也很好处理。不扯了，有问题留言区交流。

Android一次完美的跨进程服务共享实践

背景